Last year I was on a mission to try different liquid foundations in the mid-higher end range. I have my drugstore favorites by L’Oreal, but it had been quite a while since I’ve used much else and figured it was time to branch out again.
My skin can get oily so I need foundations that will hold up and look reasonably decent after a few hours. I usually go for medium/full coverage since I am prone to breakouts then hyperpigmentation after they heal or are in the process of healing. The Urban Decay All Nighter foundation sounded like something worth trying for both coverage and staying power. This foundation I think was released in 2016 so it’s been out for a while, but new to my collection last summer.
Product background: According to the description on the Ulta website: All Nighter Liquid Foundation by Urban Decay provides full coverage with a modern matte finish that never looks overdone. Get all-night wear and a blown-out effect you never thought was possible for a flawless-looking complexion that looks amazing and stays that way. Perfect for all-night affairs and other scandalous activities, this revolutionary formula is also comfortable enough to wear every day.
You get 1 oz of product for $40, so it’s not cheap by any means. But is it worth it? I’ll break it down for you based on my experience.
Packaging. Very cool pump bottle in an edgy, fun design true to the Urban Decay brand. The bottom rises as you pump product out so you won’t have to scoop anything out at the end. Less waste and you know you’re using up every last bit! Thumbs up there.
Coverage and Application. This is a very pigmented, fuller coverage foundation and more so if you use a foundation brush, but I find that when using a brush it looks a little cakey. Less is more in that situation but even so it still looks a little too heavy for me. I prefer applying it with a damp beauty sponge which helps with the cakiness, but then you lose some coverage and need more product and concealer in trouble zones. Not a big deal if you don’t have much to conceal, but I definitely need coverage so I have to work more into the skin.
Many have said this gets darker or “oxidizes” on their skin and I can confirm that to be 100% true, at least with the shades I tried. Originally I got it in the shade 6.0 but it turned much darker and orangey about a minute after applied, totally not how it looked in the bottle. Since I’m not one to like the Oompah Loompah look I returned it for 4.0 which was a much better fit. So yeah, I would recommend going a shade or two lighter.
Finish. On the dry/matte side, at least at first. If you’re looking for a hydrated dewy look you might want to stay away from this. I like to use my MAC Fix+ or Milani Make it Last spray to take away some of the dry appearance. I also like mixing this with my L’Oreal Lumi foundation-with this combo I get a foundation that is long wearing and keeps the fuller coverage, but is a lot more natural looking and hydrating. As the day goes on though it definitely doesn’t look as dry, perhaps because my skin naturally gets oily.
How it Wears. The formula feels very comfortable on the skin and stays put for a good part of the day. No sliding around which I can appreciate, though there is a little shine in my T-zone after 5/6 hours (not too bad) which I can easily blot away with a little powder. Even with that said, my skin still looks evened out out and smooth overall.
On the flip side, this tends to settle into lines and emphasize texture or bumps, so not particularly flattering in trouble zones. If you have zero blemishes or younger skin you probably have nothing to worry about. Even so it might age you since it’s drying in areas and can appear heavy depending on how it’s applied.
Here are some before/after swatch pics:
Overall Thoughts. Though I found ways to make All Nighter work for me and it can look nice, as mentioned it emphasizes texture in some spots and can settle into lines and other parts of my face. I don’t think it’s terribly noticeable unless I look really close, but then again I always look close :). For the most part it stays in place and looks smooth and not masky. The little bit of dewiness on my T-zone after a few hours isn’t a big deal, most foundations will do this on me no matter what they claim. It doesn’t feel greasy nor do I feel it on, also good points.
I will finish it and use it with a blending sponge or mix it with my Lumi foundation, but I don’t know if it’s definitely a repurchase. It’s a good foundation, not sure if it’s quite “ride-or-die” status at the moment, or different enough to warrant dropping $40 on again. If you are oily and have relatively smooth skin, it may be worth trying. Just don’t forget to go lighter!
Have you tried this or found your holy grail foundation? What are your favorites? Til next time, Jen <3